In September of 1971, my sister Cathy began her freshman year at Colby College in Waterville Maine.
Let it be known she is 6 years older than me…except for 4 days in February when we are 5 years, 361 days apart. These are my favorite days of the year.
I don’t recall exactly what she was going to get her degree in but I know she was (and is) very smart. Sadly, she got mono before she graduated and our family could not afford to keep sending her to Colby. She dropped out and was never able to return. But clearly the fire burned… a few years back, she audited a few classes at Colby but once again, could not afford to return to school and finish what she started.
The University of Maine offers free tuition to senior citizens. So Cathy decided to take some classes. And then a few more classes. And then suddenly she was on track to get her degree. Over the last few years, she has taken a few classes each semester and over the summer. She has done incredibly well and often receives great feedback from her professors. It must be fun for them to be working with a much older student. Cathy will often send me her grades and I will always tell her I am slightly disappointed and she needs to do better! Hard to do better than 100’s and A’s all the time. She knows I’m kidding with her and that I am very proud of her work.
Recently, she began a class on “Advanced Writing”. The task was to write a 2 page “Reflective Essay” Two pages isn’t much, especially for someone who excels in writing.
I present to you the actual essay she submitted;
Reflective essay ENG 205
Catherine Taylor 10-28-2025
I had the considerable good fortune to spend the Christmas holidays in Washington, DC a few years ago. High on my list of things to do that week was to see the White House Christmas tree. Since childhood, we have watched with breathless anticipation as television brought to life the annual spectacle of lighting the national holiday symbol. It sparkled like a million stars, reflecting the joy of the season and the promise of an illuminated new year to come.
But there was something else about it. It wasn’t big. As a matter of fact, it seemed rather ordinary, like a tree that would grace a town square anywhere in the country. It was surrounded by lots of smaller trees-50 of them, of course-each festooned with a Christmas wish from an individual state. They had never told us about them on TV, as if they somehow paled in comparison to the main attraction. Rather, these trees, and the modest stature of the main tree, spoke to me of the kindred spirit of Christmas, that it belongs to all of us in a shared and humble way.
And so it is with this memory close to my heart that I watched in horror as the wrecking balls and loud machines began to claw at the East Wing of the People’s House. I had visited there as well, and again was struck by the ordinariness, the homage to the past, and the honor of history. There was a frosty chill in the air, the fading winter sun dappled the worn carpet. There was a faint scent of old paper and apple cider. Holiday garlands seemed a little tattered, velvet ribbons well-worn, chairs a little dusty and moire wallpaper a little dated, but collectively charming, traditional and unpretentious, like my house and yours. This week, amidst the collective chaos, I actually felt something finally break in me; I wept for it all.
The East Wing became a home to the First Lady’s staff during the FDR presidency, and Eleanor Roosevelt greeted female reporters, Girl Scouts and many other women guests there. Under Rosalyn Carter in the 1970’s, it became the Office of the First Lady, recognizing the increasingly important role the of the spouse of the president (King). Here we find portraits of the First Ladies and framed presidential Christmas cards dating back almost two hundred years. It is no small metaphor now, to tear away the homage given to women in the White House, even as so much disrespect pervades our daily discourse.
I am old enough to remember when Jackie Kennedy invited us to the White House, as she graciously guided us through the elegant rooms-named for colors of the rainbow. We admired the doors, the dishes, the fireplaces and the artwork, and for many of us, it forged a personal connection to this proud symbol of democracy. Not fancy, but nice enough for a president and his family; they deserved such a home built on shared ideals, courage and steadfast appreciation for the somber weight of the office. Now, shattered by questionable morality, it is to become a gilded lily, as if the lily herself were not sufficiently breathtaking.
What do we do in the face of such trembling rage? Of frustration born of the reality that there is literally nothing we can do to stop it? To pound the earth in fury as colonnades tumble and know without doubt that the very foundation of our world is crunching under the order of a would-be despot. Vengeful fellows sway in his sphere and applaud, but there is no real dancing to be had. The joy of Christmas, the light, the Green Room, the French doors are all gone now. Jackie’s breathless, wispy voice echoes in the smoky wind.
When the roses are gone, what have we left? How do we reclaim the symbols of our heritage once they are carted away? How do we calm the unease at seeing the visible symbols of history torn away? What thread, what small fragment of hope can help us rebuild, maybe better than before, not as an ornate palace, but as once again a home to America and its legacy, a place where all are welcome? The East Wing once served as the portal for White House visitors; one of the many Christmas trees that stood sentry there was a tree honoring military families and their sacrifices. It is easy to say that bricks and boards are the weight bearers of our ancestry and culture, but it is more ethereal than that. America was born of nothing more than a dream of freedom; dreams may fade and swirl in the dust, but they are never really gone. We simply must not hand them over to gaudy spectacle, but rather reclaim what is rightly ours, and seize the fragments of democracy from those who seek to destroy it.
King, Rachel. “A History of the White House East Wing” Town & Country Magazine
23 October 2025
In May of this coming year, my sister Cathy will receive her Bachelor’s Degree in Political Science from the University of Maine, Farmington. It is entirely possible there will be some kind on cum laude attached to it. She will don her cap and gown and walk across the stage like every other graduate. No one, and I mean no one will be prouder of her than I will.